TheReviewTrickster's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Old Earth]

Near-perfect, exciting animation, good voice acting and great comedy. The setting and designs also look really cool. I really liked the necromancer. The "who forgets they're a wizard!?" part was amazing. Keep this up, it's really good.

[Random animation I made for school]

Animation and art aren't that good. I get it was made for class but still, nothing really interesting happens. The second part was kinda funny.

xNinja202 responds:

Sorry about that I made it at school in one day and I thought I'd just post it on Newgrounds. I understand art is an opinionated subject so I respect your viewpoint. I usually make my animations like the second half but I had to let my group do some work, but thanks for the review.

[Madness Schaufel]

Good music, although, yes, it could be more setting appropriate. I like the shovel idea but it was just kinda boring to be honest. I feel like more could have been done with the shovel in a more brutal way. Some of it was entertaining but the part where the guy had his head chopped off felt a bit flat, if you know what I mean. The animation itself was pretty nice, but the whole thing felt a bit slow. Not like gritty slow, just regular slow.

[Nier Automata [A]nimation]

Nice camera work, smooth animation and pretty nice fight choreography. Man, if you made something longer like this, it would be awesome.

[Trees]

Good animation as usual. I don't really get how they know the tree, but it was all worth it for the joke at the end. Wish it was a bit longer. Keep it up!

ChutneyGlaze responds:

Hey if it makes you feel better I don't get it either. Thanks I will keep it up!

[AGGRETSUKO: Train Trouble]

Every shot lingers for too long, the one with the grinding teeth lasted 30 whole seconds! The artstyle is uncharacteristically serious for Aggretsuko, but it is fan-made, so you obviously can't imitate the artsyle perfectly. When the llama is grinding his teeth, Retsuko looks unusually sad. Not really much animation either. Bottom line, don't extend things too long and keep practicing your animation. Although a tribute is always appreciated.

[Madness Russian Collab 1 (2009)]

Pretty low quality of animation. The only really well animated parts were the first one by Grabel, which was weirdly satisfying( the second one was also pretty good), the one by Groman, the one by K2_DuDe, which was still a bit stiff with the walking. The comic one went on a bit too long. Don't get me wrong, I like how madness fan stuff was more experimental back then, but there were some really cool moments that I would love to have seen animated and it didn't really feel very action-packed. The choice of music was pretty kickass though.

[Homer's Deathbed]

Funny but also kinda dramatic. The animation got choppy though. You perfectly mimicked the artstyles of these shows and some parts of the animation were really good, but like I said, some of it seemed to get choppy. Great concept and execution, keep at it!

[Being In A Band Sucks]

The humor has gotten repetitive. Kirsten is serious about something so Skylar keeps interrupting her to a point where it gets boring. Try to come up with some new comedy concepts. I'm not saying these fell completely flat, but you just get used to them. Also, I don't know if it's because you're making these pretty fast or I just didn't notice it before but the animation is a bit choppy. Take more time to work on these. I really liked the first two.

[The Quest for a Quest Short]

Good art and animation. The voice quality was good, and I like the concept. The joke was also funny. I need to see the rest of series, and I hope you make more.